The Response – Book Review

The Response: A Story of Fire and Flood in Britain’s New World of Extremes, by David Shukman, May 2026. Witness Books, ISBN 9781529144284, 336 pages. RRP £25 (hardback)
Toward the end of his book, David Shukman writes “throughout this project I’ve been nurturing a hope: that while so much about our deteriorating climate has not registered with people, let alone provoked much change, there’s something new that might make a difference.” That is quite a statement of faith after 20 years of work as science editor for the BBC, leading its environment coverage. I wondered just what something new might look like or what change would follow.
David Shukman’s book contains within in it some powerful stories of how climate change has had a devastating impact on individuals and communities; all of them possible candidates for that apocalyptic awakening. The stories will be familiar to readers. Remember when the UK hit 40ºC back in July 2022 and we had urban wildfires? Shukman tells the stories of Wennington (and Dagenham) where several houses were burnt down. The aftermath revealed the usual litany of lack of preparedness, although particularly shocking was to read that the water company had reduced the water pressure for the day to carry out some tests, so there was not enough water available to the fire crews working at full stretch. Our water companies seem to excel best at shareholder remuneration, rather than keeping our water systems in good shape.
There are other equally compelling stories well told – Tony, trapped up to his chin in sewage in his flooded basement in Hampstead in 2021, rescued by a couple of observant neighbours after he had thought he had made his last phone call. There is the story of Ella Roberta, the young girl who lived on the South Circular and died of asthma contributed to by exposure to excessive air pollution. It was the courageous persistence of Ella’s mother Rosamund Adoo-Kissis-Debrah, who led the campaign for her death not to have been in vain, that was in part at least the reason for the London Mayor, Sadiq Khan’s determination to introduce the Ultra Low Emission Zones to improve air quality for Londoners. Elsewhere we hear about hospital systems failing in extreme heat and fragmented services with responsibilities falling between agencies, as well as of worthy individuals doing their best to make a difference.
It seems so familiar, though, as records (including flood, heat and wildfires) continue to be broken year on year with no real sign on the horizon of that something that might make a difference. ‘Adapt or Die’ was the strap line of one chair of the environment agency – punchy enough but it didn’t really seem to land. ‘Protect What You Love’ is the title of David Skukman’s last chapter, a catch all phrase that can contract or expand as desired, which makes it a good strap line for the call for adaptation being embraced by the Climate Majority Project, Reform UK and BlackRock Capital. Now there is a big tent. Maybe it is through such inchoate alliances that we will develop the necessary solidarities and imaginations to find ways forward for both people and planet. I am doubtful, though.
Jonathan Morris


Leave a Reply